Discussion about this post

User's avatar
MJ Lee's avatar

Thank you for your extensive reply! So I’ve seen all but 1 of the films on which you based your statistic (I watched a different version of 2 Half-times in Hell). I guess we differ on definition of “major character”. In most of your list, the character who died was in the protagonist’s past or background, not necessarily even during the film. Or if present, a bit part. So I didn’t think of that as a major character. I did overlook Cool Kids Don’t Cry. United is a Busby Babes storyline. And I forgot another — Will — where the dad dies in the first 10 minutes — to me still not a major character. But yes, small sample size skews statistics. Thanks again for thinking about this!

Expand full comment
MJ Lee's avatar

Hi Stephen, I love your work, thank you for doing this. However, I am curious about your soccer/european football stat that 10% of such films have a major character die. I have reviewed almost 500 soccer movies (half of them documentaries), and of the 250-ish narrative films, I can't recall many major characters dying. The only ones I can think of are the features about the Busby babes. My hobby website is soccermoviemom.com.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...