Certainly not. Sound design and mixing achievements often reflect more than just the explosions in a film. This perspective oversimplifies what the award represents. To reach a real conclusion, you must listen in a theater or on a system that lets you experience the design and mix. Otherwise, discussion is impossible. On a standard large-screen television with a typical sound setup, it is understandable why you might assume the award centers on explosions.
Well, that’s a different argument—perhaps a strong one. You would need to gather actual data on it. For now, it remains a suspicion. One point to weigh is that even if voters are not sound designers, they all bring experience with film, both narrative and technical; they understand how a sound mix conveys performance and makes the moving parts legible, even without that title. It is not quite a shot in the dark.
I don’t quite follow (ironic, I know). The data can only ever show the correlation, not the causation. There is a link between the factors attributes of the film and their outcomes at awards. Why that link exists is something I’m keen to hear everyone’s thoughts on.
For me it comes down to the shorthands we all use when having to choose something without the full information. We gravitate towards brands, famous faces, and associations we’ve picked up along the way.
I totally agree that the complexity of the sound work isn't captured here, or indeed when picking which films should be rewarded. The point of the research is to show that people often use heuristics and shorthand when coming to what should be a more nuanced assessment.
The vast majority of people voting for the winner are not sound professionals, and I would guess many of them only saw the movies at home. You're right that it should be more than this pov, but the data suggests it may not work that way in practice.
Certainly not. Sound design and mixing achievements often reflect more than just the explosions in a film. This perspective oversimplifies what the award represents. To reach a real conclusion, you must listen in a theater or on a system that lets you experience the design and mix. Otherwise, discussion is impossible. On a standard large-screen television with a typical sound setup, it is understandable why you might assume the award centers on explosions.
Well, that’s a different argument—perhaps a strong one. You would need to gather actual data on it. For now, it remains a suspicion. One point to weigh is that even if voters are not sound designers, they all bring experience with film, both narrative and technical; they understand how a sound mix conveys performance and makes the moving parts legible, even without that title. It is not quite a shot in the dark.
I don’t quite follow (ironic, I know). The data can only ever show the correlation, not the causation. There is a link between the factors attributes of the film and their outcomes at awards. Why that link exists is something I’m keen to hear everyone’s thoughts on.
For me it comes down to the shorthands we all use when having to choose something without the full information. We gravitate towards brands, famous faces, and associations we’ve picked up along the way.
That was funny. I mean the part about irony
I totally agree that the complexity of the sound work isn't captured here, or indeed when picking which films should be rewarded. The point of the research is to show that people often use heuristics and shorthand when coming to what should be a more nuanced assessment.
The vast majority of people voting for the winner are not sound professionals, and I would guess many of them only saw the movies at home. You're right that it should be more than this pov, but the data suggests it may not work that way in practice.
Great piece Stephen - appreciate the deep dives. You should partner with Myth Busters and do all the old saws across Hollywood and beyond...